Thursday, 29 May 2014

Double Mint Choc Chip Ice Cream

What happened to summer? One minute it was here and the next, gone........... After the wet winter, I am really hoping the weather takes a better turn. But sunshine or not, I intend to make (and eat) lots of ice-cream. And at least when the weather's cold, you have longer to savour the deliciousness and luxury before it melts into a creamy puddle.

I love ice-cream. Any ice-cream. Comforting and soothing........... We always have at least two tubs on the go in the freezer. I haven't yet resorted to the comedic grab the whole tub and sit with a large spoon in front of the TV scene, but I have come close to it on many occasions. If I didn't think my family might consider I had finally lost it, then I would be there..... really!

Home made ice-cream tastes so much better than shop-bought tubs. It may of course just be psychological, but the thought and care that goes into making ice cream in your own kitchen makes it that little bit more special. It's always fun to play with different ingredients and flavours, but sometimes it's just good to lean on the old favourites.

Mint-Choc Chip is one of life's delights. It seems to have been around forever and is always a winner. The cold, refreshing mintyness, contrasting with the dark, slightly bitter chocolate crunch and sweet creaminess of the ice-cream is loved by young and old alike. So when I asked my daughter 'what flavour ice-cream should I make?', the answer was instantaneous, and Mint Choc Chip was the order of the day.

To make the ice-cream taste as natural as possible, I used a couple of handfuls of fresh mint, infused with the custard as it cooked, carefully crushing to encourage the flavours to mingle. The resulting ice-cream base was definitely pretty minty, but it was not quite there. Fresh mint has an earthy flavour which is fine, but I wanted the ice-cream to have the expected cold, ice-mint freshness. To compensate, I balanced it with a little natural mint extract. The flavour of the fresh mint still came through strongly, but was nicely tempered and I think, more palatable.

The chocolate 'chips' come from dark, rich chocolate which has been frozen and smashed into pieces, before being added. There is also an extra mint kick from a few broken After Eights, folded in for good measure. The After Eights are optional, but add an interesting slightly chewy dimension when they have been frozen. If you don't want to use After Eights, add extra dark chocolate to make up the chocolate weight (about 110g in total).

The After Eights made great decoration too........... Cutting them with a small cookie cutter was amazingly easy and made the served ice-cream that little bit more special!

I think this ice-cream has been devoured faster than any other I have made............ Two days and gone! Doesn't that say it all?

Double Mint Choc Chip Ice Cream (makes 1 litre)


45g dark chocolate
After Eight Mints (or equivalent soft fondant centred chocolate-covered mints)
400 ml whole milk
350 ml double cream
1 teaspoon vanilla extract
approx 18 large fresh mint leaves 
4 large egg yolks
140g caster sugar
½ to 1 teaspoon natural peppermint extract (to taste)
green food dye paste (or a couple of drops of green food dye) to desired colour (optional)


  1. Place the chocolate and After Eights in a freezer bag and place in the freezer for a couple of hours (or overnight).
  2. When frozen, smash the chocolate in the bag with a rolling pin until it is broken into very small pieces. Place back in the freezer until ready to use.
  3. Pour the milk and cream into a large saucepan with the vanilla extract and mint leaves (which you should crush slightly before adding). Stir and then heat on a low to medium setting until almost boiling (just starting to form small bubbles, but not boiling), then turn off the heat and cover with a lid, leaving to sit and steep for about 15 minutes. 
  4. Meanwhile, whisk the egg yolks with the sugar until thick and pale.
  5. Pour about half of the cooling cream mixture (without leaves), a little at a time, into the egg-sugar paste, whisking continually to combine thoroughly.
  6. Pour this mixture back into the saucepan to add to the rest of the cream-liquid.
  7. Heat on a low setting, stirring continually until the custard thickens to a consistency which coats the back of the spoon. Do NOT allow to boil, although the custard can form small bubbles.
  8. Pour the custard through a sieve into a bowl and add mint extract and food colour to desired taste and appearance. 
  9. Allow the mixture to cool as quickly as possible, stirring intermittently to prevent a skin forming. When cool enough, place in the fridge.
  10. Chill the custard for several hours (preferably overnight).
  11. Churn using an ice cream maker by the manufacturers instructions.
  12. When the churning process is complete, fold the broken chocolate and After Eights through the ice cream whilst it is still soft enough to do so.
  13. Spoon the finished ice cream into an airtight container and place in the freezer to allow to  harden, although you may wish to serve soft straight away. 

  14. (If you don't have an ice cream maker, place the mixture at stage 11 into a shallow container and freeze until mushy. Then turn into a chilled bowl and beat until the ice crystals are broken down. Return to the freezer and freeze again until mushy. Repeat the whisking, add the chocolate pieces and freeze a final time)
Gluten Free Alchemist © 2013-14 unless otherwise indicated


  1. Homemade Ice Cream is so much better than store bought, I completely agree with you. It's starting to warm up here in the US, so this recipe sounds so good right now-yum!

    1. Thanks Carol. Good to hear it is warming up where you are..... I agree minty ice cream is best when it warms up...... nicely refreshing!

  2. This looks fantastic. Mint choc chip was always my favourite growing up but we never had it that often as my siblings always preferred plain chocolate.
    Love the idea of using some of the after eights for the choc pieces. I've added large chunks of block chocolate to ice cream in the past, thinking it would be good but they have gone too hard, but this sounds ideal. We just need the weather to enjoy it now!

    1. That sounds unfair! I think I would have demanded an ice-cream choosing rota. Hopefully the weather will heat up soon and you can make up for childhood minty ice-cream deprivation!

  3. One of my favorite types of ice cream! This looks amazing! Wishing I had a big bowl right now!

    1. Thanks Pamela. One of my favourites too! I'd send you some, but it wouldn't last the distance!

  4. mint and chocolate? yes please :) I love the little heart after eight - great idea!

    1. It is a bit of a favourite pairing! My daughter asked me where I bought the After Eight hearts. She seemed very impressed that I had 'made' them, especially as she got to eat all the off-cuts!


I always LOVE to hear from you, so please leave a comment, share your thoughts and stay in touch.

By leaving a comment, you consent to any personal information you choose to share being collected by Gluten Free Alchemist for statistical and monitoring purposes and you enter into a public conversation linked to the post. You may choose to make your comment anonymous by ticking the relevant check-box. For full details of the GFA Privacy Policy, please click on the signposted label at the top of the page.